A Man Is Not Dead Until He Is Forgotten

 

 


WHAT I CAN DO - I WILL -

 

name
Panel 17 W, Line 26



Carl Joseph Ellerd was an Aviation Structural Mechanic (Hydraulics) Second Class in the United States Navy when he was killed in North Vietnam (over water) on 02 October 1969. Ellerd was born on 27 November 1939, and his home city of record is Odessa, Texas. Ellerd's remains have not been returned.





The C-2A Greyhound

The C-2A Greyhound provided critical logistics support to aircraft carriers around the world. Its primary mission was to transport personnel including litter patients during medical evacuation missions, supplies, mail, or a combination thereof, to and from the carrier task force to which it was assigned. Powered by two PT-6 turboprop engines, the Greyhound was able to deliver a payload of up to 10,000 pounds. Priority cargos, such as jet engines, were stored within the aircraft’s cage restraint system and could be transported from ship to shore in a matter of hours. For fast turnaround operations, the onboard power winch allowed for straight-in rear cargo loading and downloading through its large aft cargo ramp and door. Further, the C-2A’s open-ramp flight capability allowed for airdrop of supplies and personnel from carrier-launched aircraft. The Greyhound also had folding wings and an onboard auxiliary power unit for engine starting and ground power self-sufficiency in remote areas that provided it with an operational versatility found in no other cargo aircraft




The Incident

On 2 October 1969, a C2A from Fleet Tactical Support Squadron 50, NAS Atsugi, Japan was transferring crewmen from Naval Air Station Cubi Point, Republic of the Philippines to the USS Constellation task force located in the Gulf of Tonkin. The crew of the C2A assigned to this early morning flight was comprised of Lt. Herbert H. Dilger, pilot; Lt. Richard A. Livingston, co-pilot; AMS3 Rayford J. Hill, crewmember; ADJ3 Paul K. Moser, crewmember; and ADJ3 Michael J. Tye, crewmember.

Those sailors returning to the USS Constellation were: HE3 Terry L. Beck, ATR3 Richard W. Bell, ASE3 Michael L. Bowman, Mr. Frank L. Bytheway, HM2 Donald C. Dean, AMH2 Carl J. Ellerd, AE2 James J. Fowler, AME3 Roy G. Fowler, MM1 Paul E. Gore, ABH3 William D. Goresuch, AMS3 Delvin L. Kohker, AN Howard M. Koslosky, FTM2 Robert B. Leonard, AQB2 Ronald W. Montgomery, ADJ2 Kenneth M. Prentice, SD2 Fidel G. Salazar and DS3 Keavin L. Terrell. Some of these men were returning to their ship after liberty while others were going to new duty stations on board the aircraft carrier.

With the exception of Frank Bytheway, a civilian, everyone else on this aircraft was US Navy personnel. While Mr. Bytheway was manifested on this flight, there is no record of why he was traveling to the USS Constellation. Further, for unknown reasons, he is not carried on the US government list of unaccounted for Americans.

Passengers onboard the Greyhound whose final destination was other ships in the carrier group task force were: PN1 Rolando C. Dayao and YNC Leonardo M. Gan who were returning to the Destroyer USS Walke, TN Reynaldo R. Viado who was returning to the Destroyer USS Hamner, and MM2 William R. Moore who was destined for the Guided Missile Cruiser USS Long Beach.

After take off, Lt. Dilger reported "Ops Normal." Communications with other squadron aircraft and the carrier's air control center indicated operations were normal. The carrier's radar continued tracking the Greyhound until approximately 55 minutes after takeoff, when radar contact was lost. The last radar position was approximately 26 miles out from the USS Constellation. That position was also 68 miles due east of the North Vietnamese coastline, 68 miles northeast of Dong Hoi, 137 miles southeast of Vinh, North Vietnam; and 82 miles southwest of Hainan Island, China.

An extensive search and rescue (SAR) operation was immediately initiated. Shortly thereafter other aircraft in the area began sighting an oil slick and debris. A search and recovery helicopter launched from the ship was able to recover a few pieces of the aircraft. The recovered debris indicated that the aircraft was in a relatively high-speed nose down, right wing down impact with the water, or a possible right wing failure before impact. During the thorough search no bodies of the crew and passengers were found. At the time the formal search was terminated all 26 men were reported as Killed /Body Not Recovered.

There is virtually no chance that the crew and passengers onboard the C2A Greyhound can ever be recovered due to the type of loss. However, each man has the right not to be forgotten by the nation he gave his life for.




Sources

Biographical and incident of loss information was obtained from either POW/NET and/or Task Force Omega, Inc (unless otherwise noted). Additional information may be found via remembrances at The Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund or The Virtual Wall Vietnam Veterans Memorial.




{line}
List | E01 | E02 | E03 | E04
{line}

 

Copyright Stacey N. Binning 1998 - 2007.